108项测试验证 告诉您SP1、SP2谁更快
发布日期：2004年10月18日 作者：deric 编辑：deric
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
第1页：新装的SP2，比SP1多耗42MB内存第2页：SP2 vs. SP1：基准性能测试第3页：SP2 vs. SP1：游戏性能对比第4页：SP2 vs. SP1：应用性能测试第5页：总成绩：SP1比SP2要快0.5%……
第1页：新装的SP2，比SP1多耗42MB内存
微软Windows XP SP2已经发布有一段时间，无数的用户已经安装。抛开新补丁的新功能特性不谈，咱们今天就来看看SP2的性能到底如何。虽然这样的测试有些不全面，但我想还是会有很多朋友关心的。
以下是重新安装系统后，“干净”的情况下SP1和SP2的对比，我们看到SP2增加了4个进程，比SP1系统多耗用了42MB内存空间。
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-14-33-78444351.jpg
SP1
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-14-34-43577925.jpg
SP2
接下来，我们将用流行的游戏、软件来对SP1和SP2的性能进行对比。
第2页：SP2 vs. SP1：基准性能测试
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-10-722941297.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-11-81746324.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-12-78444351.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-13-221290310.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-14-973766790.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-15-419777023.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-16-722941297.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-16-17-26105571.gif
第3页：SP2 vs. SP1：游戏性能对比
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-20-35-935598392.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-20-30-437249378.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-20-24-43577925.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-20-23-524454584.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-20-22-168951530.gif
第4页：SP2 vs. SP1：应用性能测试
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-22-57-43577925.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-0-60971996.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-3-670602517.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-4-632434118.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-6-918126037.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-9-384910598.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-12-726243270.gif
http://www.pcpop.com/pcpopimg/04/10/18-10-23-12-726243270.gif
第5页：总成绩：SP1比SP2要快0.5%……
在108个测试成绩中，SP1赢了63个。下面是成绩的总结表：
All resolution scores combined
SP1 score
SP2 score
SP 1 Percentage faster than SP2
3D Mark 2003
31684
30888
2.6%
3D Mark 2005
12689
12399
2.3%
Aquamark
AA off, Aniso Off Details vlow
546
542
0.7%
AA off, Aniso Off Details vhigh
217
239
-9.3%
AA 6x, Aniso 16x Details vlow
400
393
1.7%
AA 6x, Aniso 16x Details vhigh
173
205
-15.5%
Doom III
130
130
0.0%
GL Excess
66274
66082
0.3%
N-Bench 3 (1024x768 and 1600x1200 scores combined)
Integer 1 (Landscape)
6148
6094
0.9%
Integer 2 (Mandelbrot)
5796
5796
0.0%
Float 1 (Flock)
4950
5045
-1.9%
Float 2 (Rigid Body)
4977
4919
1.2%
CPU Overall
5467
5463
0.1%
Ninja 1
8122
8069
0.7%
Ninja 2
6914
6873
0.6%
Grand Touring
8469
8423
0.5%
Star Fighter
7258
7281
-0.3%
3D Overall
7690
7661
0.4%
Overall Score
6578
6562
0.2%
PCMark 2004
4781
4761
0.4%
Quake III high quality v.11
1640
1592
3.0%
Serious Sam
586
592
-1.0%
Splinter Cell Chinese Embassy
449
445
0.8%
UT2004 - Umark utility - 16 bots BR-Colossus - High Image Quality
585
577
1.4%
UT2003 - flyby
845
868
-2.7%
Wolfenstein Enemy Territory (railgun demo)
434
451
-3.8%
X2 Rolling demo
106
107
-0.9%
Sisoft Sandra CPU Arithmetic
18662
18746
-0.4%
Sisoft Sandra CPU Multi Media Benchmark
41543
41519
0.1%
Sisoft Sandra Memory Bandwidth
11740
11704
0.3%
SpecviewPerf 8.1
98.7
98.1
0.6%
After Effects 6.0
2.11
2.07
-1.9%
总体成绩是，同一台PC，安装SP1后性能比SP2要高0.5%，差距非常之小，已经可以基本忽略了。考虑到SP2的众多新功能新特性，看来大家还是安装吧。
|
发表于 2005-1-13 01:21
| 
发表于 2005-1-14 16:04
| 
